The Value of Staying in the Classroom: Not Everyone Wants to Lead

by Andrew Dalton, Group Director of Education, International Schools @Parkcity Group

November 23, 2025

Updated November 23, 2025

Not every great teacher aspires to lead, and schools are stronger when passionate educators choose to stay in the classroom, doing what they do best.

In a profession that often equates success with climbing the leadership ladder, it is easy to overlook those who quietly choose to remain where their impact is most direct, in the classroom. Yet, in schools across all age groups, these teachers are often the steady heartbeat of a thriving school community.

Career progression in education tends to follow a well-trodden path. A talented teacher becomes a Head of Year, then perhaps a Head of Department or Curriculum Coordinator, and before long, they are being nudged toward assistant headship or leadership roles. The assumption is that professional growth means moving away from daily teaching, yet for many, the classroom is not a stepping stone, it is their destination.

Some of the most dedicated and skilled professionals find their deepest satisfaction in the daily routine of teaching. They thrive on nurturing young children’s curiosity in Kindergarten, helping Primary students build confidence and independence, or guiding Secondary students through the complexity of academic subjects, examinations, and adolescence. Their motivation comes not from line management responsibilities or school wide strategy, but from the learning moments they create, the relationships they build, and the lives they shape.

Schools can benefit enormously from these long-serving classroom teachers. With transient populations and frequent staff turnover, continuity and institutional memory are invaluable. A teacher who has stayed in one school for a decade often becomes a cultural anchor, a trusted mentor to colleagues, a reassuring presence for students, and a living embodiment of the school’s ethos.

However, valuing these teachers requires more than quiet appreciation. Schools need to ensure that their career structures and appraisal systems recognise mastery and longevity in teaching as legitimate forms of progression. Too often, teachers feel compelled to take on leadership posts simply because that is where recognition and higher pay reside. By broadening definitions of success, schools can celebrate excellence in practice, not just hierarchy.

Professional growth does not always mean managing others. It can mean deepening expertise in pedagogy, mentoring younger colleagues, contributing to curriculum design, or leading initiatives in wellbeing, sustainability, or inclusion. Some teachers are extraordinary practitioners who lift the quality of teaching across an entire school without ever needing a title, and often without realising.

Of course, leadership remains essential. Schools need visionary Heads, Principals, Coordinators, and Department Heads to set direction and shape culture. Yet those roles are not for everyone, and they should not have to be. When a teacher chooses to stay in the classroom, it should be seen not as a lack of ambition but as a clear understanding of where their greatest strengths and joys lie.

In recent years, as education becomes more complex and pressured, many schools are rediscovering the importance of teacher retention. Stability and quality in the classroom directly translate into better outcomes for students. A passionate, experienced teacher who loves their craft is often more valuable than an ambitious leader who has left teaching behind.

Ultimately, every strong school depends on balance: those who lead and those who teach, those who manage systems and those who shape minds. The best school leaders recognise this and intentionally create environments where teachers at every stage of their career feel respected, supported, and inspired to keep growing, whether that growth takes them into leadership or keeps them joyfully in front of a class of eager learners.

To summarise, when teachers are empowered to follow their own professional calling, everyone wins, especially the students.

About Teacher Recruit

For years, teacher recruitment has been monotonous and expensive. Teacher Recruit is an App that simplifies this. It globally matches teachers and schools instantly.

Register

Create your account on Teacher Recruit and receive our top tips for your job hunt in your inbox.